Hollyoaks fans thought they had seen the last of James Nightingale when a car exploded in 2024. Then, during the soap's 30th anniversary week in October 2025, he was back. Gregory Finnegan has played the scheming lawyer in Channel 4's Hollyoaks since January 2016, and the part won him Best Actor at the 2019 British Soap Awards. The British actor was born in England in 1980.
Gregory Finnegan's training
Finnegan trained at the Webber Douglas Academy of Dramatic Art.
Gregory Finnegan's career before Hollyoaks
His television debut was as Gabriel Brennan in Sky One's Is Harry on the Boat?. Drama roles followed in the BBC One spy thriller Spooks, The Last Detective, Channel 4's The Courtroom, Mile High and Agatha Christie: A Life in Pictures, and he was cast in the film Winter Solstice.
Soap work began in 2005, when he played Nigel Dudley in Family Affairs. Medical dramas have been a regular stop: he was Owen Stanway in Casualty, Dr Alex Arnott in a single EastEnders episode, and appeared twice in Doctors, as Duncan Montague in 2011 and David Hewitt a year later. He also played a computer expert in Blitz, Terry in the short Fuse and Henry Kendrick in Valentine's Kiss.
How Gregory Finnegan became James Nightingale
His casting was announced on Christmas Eve 2015, with James billed as a mysterious lawyer. He made his first appearance on 12 January 2016, offering legal help to Cindy Cunningham, played by Stephanie Waring, and urging her to go after the assets of Mac Nightingale. The twist soon followed: James was Mac's eldest son, working with his mother Marnie against his own father.
Who is James Nightingale in Hollyoaks?
James is openly gay, sharp-suited and driven by a simple rule: if he wants something, he gets it. Blackmail and manipulation are his tools of choice, and critics have called him Machiavellian. Finnegan has defended the character, explaining that the writers later revealed a painful backstory, including that Mac regularly beat James as a child.
James Nightingale's biggest storylines
Within weeks of arriving, James and Marnie set out to steal the Hutchinsons' restaurant, The Hutch. James pretended to fancy Scott Drinkwell to use him against the business, then offered Harry Thompson ten thousand pounds to sleep with him. Harry accepted, and the pair later used that secret to blackmail him. The restaurant became "Nightingales", and when Harry hit back with a fake kidnap scam, James told Ste Hay, played by Kieron Richardson, about Harry's infidelity.
Next he charmed John Paul McQueen away from Scott and struck up a friendship with fellow schemer Joanne Cardsley, the pair betting on who could break up a couple first. He also helped Neeta Kaur bankrupt Mac after Mac drained her money. A historical abuse storyline involving his father brought out a more vulnerable side, and he has shared family scenes with Oscar Curtis, who plays Lucas Hay.
His bitter rivalry with Ste eventually turned to love, and the pair married in 2023. In September 2024 James was believed to have died in a car explosion, an event that left Ste in a coma. He made a surprise return on 15 October 2025.
Awards and nominations
Finnegan was shortlisted for Best Actor at the 2017 British Soap Awards and longlisted for Best Actor and Bad Boy at that year's Inside Soap Awards. In 2019 the British Soap Awards named him Best Actor for playing James.
Is Gregory Finnegan still in Hollyoaks?
James's return in October 2025 brought Finnegan back to Hollyoaks after the character's apparent death the previous year.