Kevin McGarry found acting by accident: as a first-year high school student he walked into a theatre class meant for 12th-graders. That chance moment led to years on Canadian stages, a run as ranch hand Mitch Cutty in Heartland from 2016 to 2021, and a leading role in Hallmark Channel's When Calls the Heart.
Today the Canadian actor is also known for writing and directing, and for a long list of romantic TV movies.
Kevin McGarry's early life and training
McGarry was born on 18 March 1985 in Kincardine, Ontario. After that unplanned start in drama at school, he attended George Brown College, took theatre at Fanshawe College and later trained at Pro Actors Lab in Toronto.
From the stage to the screen
Theatre came first. McGarry performed at the Shaw Festival and the Charlottetown Festival, with credits including A Midsummer Night's Dream, Anne of Green Gables, The Full Monty, Enchanted April, Come Back, Little Sheba and She Loves Me.
On screen he built up guest parts in series such as Being Erica (2009), Murdoch Mysteries (2015), Private Eyes (2016), Saving Hope (2017), The Bold Type (2018) and Schitt's Creek (2020). He made his feature film debut in 2010, with a minor part in Saw 3D: The Final Chapter.
His breakthrough arrived in 2015, when he took the lead as Dr Timothy "Hud" Hudson in the YTV medical drama Open Heart, which ran for 12 episodes.
Kevin McGarry as Mitch Cutty in Heartland
McGarry starred in the CBC family drama from 2016 to 2021. Mitch is taken on as a ranch hand and has to work hard to win over the family β especially Jack and Tim. After plenty of friction, Tim gives him the nickname "Trooper", after a tough but well-respected bronc on the rodeo circuit.
An awkward first date with Lou leads to an on-again, off-again romance. Mitch carries guilt over losing his cousin to PTSD, and opening up to Lou helps the pair build trust. When they split, Mitch starts seeing a yoga teacher called Maya β which forces Lou to face how she really feels about him.
Nathan Grant in When Calls the Heart
In 2019 McGarry joined Hallmark Channel's When Calls the Heart in season 6 as Constable Nathan Grant, a Mountie with strong principles, and he has stayed at the centre of the show next to its lead, Erin Krakow. His storylines include Nathan's bond with his adopted daughter, Allie.
The series has been a ratings success: by March 2025, Nielsen figures put season 12 as the most-watched entertainment programme on cable that year, reaching 6.1 million unduplicated viewers over 12 episodes. Hallmark renewed the show for a 13th season, due to premiere in 2026.
Kevin McGarry's other films and TV shows
The role opened the door to many more Hallmark leads. McGarry plays Peter Hastings, a wealthy man who falls for Lacey Chabert's character Avery, in The Wedding Veil trilogy β The Wedding Veil and The Wedding Veil Legacy (both 2022) and The Wedding Veil Expectations (2023).
His TV movies also include Signed, Sealed, Delivered: From Paris With Love, released in 2015, Autumn Stables (2018), Winter Castle (2019), A Very Corgi Christmas (2019), Checkin' It Twice (2023) and A Reason for the Season (2024). In 2025 he filmed Villa Amore in Italy opposite Eloise Mumford, playing Leo, a lawyer who moves there to help his grandmother.
Also in 2025, he appeared in four episodes of the fourth season of Family Law as a possible love interest for Jewel Staite's character, Abby Bianchi. Earlier guest credits include The Night Agent (2023).
Writing and directing
McGarry co-wrote the biopic Hugh & I (2014), which picked up the Patron's Pick award at the 2014 Toronto Fringe Festival. He also wrote the play Nebraska (2009) and in 2016 directed a short film, Happy F#@%ing New Year.
Is Kevin McGarry married?
Yes β to actress Kayla Wallace, who also stars in When Calls the Heart. The couple confirmed they were together in 2020, got engaged in 2022 and announced their marriage in 2024. They have also worked together on two Hallmark films from 2022, Feeling Butterflies and My Grown-Up Christmas List.
In November 2025 they revealed they were expecting a baby, and in May 2026 they announced the birth of their first child.