Robert Sugden has been played by three different actors, and the first of them, Christopher Smith, was just four years old when he won the part. Recasting is part of soap life: children grow up, actors move on, and characters come home years later with a new face. If you have ever watched a familiar name walk back on screen and wondered who played them before, this guide has the answer.
Below we go show by show through Coronation Street, EastEnders, Emmerdale, Hollyoaks and Home and Away, naming the original actor, anyone in between, and who plays the role now. A quick-reference table sits at the end.
Why do soaps recast characters?
The stories behind these switches follow a few familiar patterns. Many child characters were recast so they could move into grown-up storylines, as happened with Robert Sugden, Victoria Sugden and Adam Barlow. In other cases the original actor chose not to return when producers wanted the character back, which is how Johnny Carter and Ryan Connor ended up with new faces.
Some actors left to try other work, and a few characters simply stayed off screen for so long that a fresh casting made sense. Vicki Fowler, for example, was away from Walford for 21 years.
Which Coronation Street characters have been recast?
Adam Barlow
The first Adam was Scottish actor Iain De Caestecker, who played him as a boy from 2001 to 2003, clocking up 54 episodes. He went on to international fame as scientist Leo Fitz in the Marvel series Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.
Producers then wanted an older actor, and Sam Robertson from Dundee took over in 2004. He left university at 18 to concentrate on the part, stayed until 2007 and came back in 2016. Sam Robertson plays Adam today.
Nick Tilsley
Adam Rickitt was cast as Nick in 1997 after auditioning almost as a joke, having never watched an episode. He left in 1999 to launch a pop career, scoring a UK top-five single, and returned from 2002 to 2004. His time in the role included the soap's first gay kiss in 2003.
The current Nick is Ben Price, who has played him since 2009. Viewers may also remember him as England captain Conrad Gates in Footballers' Wives.
Ryan Connor
Three actors have played Ryan. The original was Ben Thompson, who joined in 2006 after first auditioning for a different part. When Ryan was brought back in 2012, Thompson declined to return, so Sol Heras took over until 2013.
In 2018 the character was recast once more, with former Emmerdale actor Ryan Prescott stepping in. He has played Ryan ever since.
Summer Spellman
Matilda Freeman created the role of Summer in June 2017 and appeared in 147 episodes. In 2020 she left after three and a half years to pursue other acting work.
Harriet Bibby took over later that year. She was 22 when she landed the part of a 16-year-old, and a year later she was nominated for Best Newcomer at the Inside Soap Awards. She still plays Summer.
Todd Grimshaw
Bruno Langley was the original Todd, the programme's first openly gay character, playing him across more than 700 episodes in several stints between 2001 and 2017. His contract was ended in 2017 after he was charged with, and then pleaded guilty to, sexual assault.
The role went to Welsh actor and musician Gareth Pierce, whose casting was announced in August 2020. He also voices Gavin Moss in The Archers on BBC Radio 4.
Tracy Barlow
Tracy has had four actresses. Christabel Finch played her as a baby from 1977 to 1983, followed by Holly Chamarette from 1985 to 1988. Dawn Acton became the third Tracy in 1988 and stayed for eleven years, leaving in 1999 aged 22. She now works as a DJ.
Kate Ford arrived in autumn 2002 and gave Tracy a much sharper edge, winning British Soap Awards for the role. She took a break between 2007 and 2010, and remains Tracy today.
Which EastEnders characters have been recast?
Ash Panesar
Gurlaine Kaur Garcha first played Dr Ash Panesar from 2019, leaving the show in March 2023. In 2026 the role passed to Sakira Vel, whose first episode went out in September that year.
Vel has an unusual link to her character: before switching to acting in 2024, she spent more than ten years working as an emergency medicine doctor.
Chelsea Fox
The original Chelsea was Tiana Benjamin, who played her from 2006 to 2010. Film fans may know her as Angelina Johnson in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire.
Chelsea came back ten years later with Zaraah Abrahams in the role. Her first episode aired on Christmas Day 2020, and she has played Chelsea since. She had earlier appeared in Coronation Street and Waterloo Road.
Elaine Peacock
Linda Carter's mother was first played by musical theatre star Maria Friedman, a three-time Olivier Award winner, from 2014 to 2017. When Elaine was recast in 2023, the part went to Harriet Thorpe, familiar from The Brittas Empire and Absolutely Fabulous.
Johnny Carter
Sam Strike played Johnny from Boxing Day 2013 until 2014, and his coming-out scenes with screen dad Mick won a Media Recognition Award from Attitude magazine. When producers brought Johnny back in 2016, Strike chose not to return; he went on to play the title role in the film Leatherface.
Ted Reilly took over from April 2016 until January 2018. The third and current Johnny is Brighton-born Charlie Suff, who arrived in February 2024. In August 2026 it was reported that he would be leaving the soap.
Lauren Branning
Madeline Duggan made her debut as Lauren on 3 July 2006 and played her for almost four years, until she was dropped in May 2010. Before that, she had played Little Cosette in Les MisΓ©rables in the West End.
Jacqueline Jossa became Lauren in September 2010 and won Best Newcomer at the National Television Awards in 2012. She left in 2018, returned for a permanent stay in 2023, and still plays the role.
Mark Fowler
In 2016 Ned Porteous had a short run as Mark Fowler, appearing in 13 episodes between August and September. He later found success as Joe Tate in Emmerdale and as Lord Wetherby in Bridgerton.
Ten years on, the role went to Stephen Aaron-Sipple, who was announced as the new Mark in January 2026. He had previously trained as a firefighter and played John Taylor in the Danish crime drama Oxen.
Penny Branning
As a child, Mia McKenna-Bruce played young Penny in two short guest stints in 2008. She later won the BAFTA Rising Star Award for her lead role in the film How to Have Sex.
Penny returned as an adult in 2024, played by Kitty Castledine, a LAMDA-trained actress. She has spoken about her pride in helping to make disability visible on television.
Peter Beale
Peter has been played by seven actors, and the current one has had two goes at the part. Thomas Law became the fifth Peter in 2006, taking over from James Martin, and stayed until December 2010.
Ben Hardy followed from 2013 to 2015, before moving into films such as Bohemian Rhapsody, in which he played Queen drummer Roger Taylor. Dayle Hudson, a former bricklayer, took over in February 2020 and played Peter until 2022. Then, in June 2023, Thomas Law returned without any advance announcement and has played Peter ever since.
Vicki Fowler
Scarlett Alice Johnson played Vicki in her first television role, from 2003 until the end of 2004, appearing in 194 episodes. She went on to star in the BBC Three sitcom Pramface.
Vicki came back to Walford in 2025 after a gap of 21 years, now played by Alice Haig, daughter of actor David Haig. Her earlier credits include Rain Dogs and The Day of the Jackal.
Which Emmerdale characters have been recast?
Matty Barton
Grace Cassidy played the character from July 2009 until 2012, when the character was known as Hannah Barton. She had earlier played Rachel Towers in Grange Hill, and later trained at RADA.
Years later the character returned as Matty Barton, a trans man who had transitioned off screen, played by Ash Palmisciano since 2018. Matty was the soap's first trans character and Palmisciano its first trans cast member. He was named Best Newcomer at the 2018 Inside Soap Awards.
Robert Sugden
Christopher Smith was picked from around 50 children to play Robert, starting in 1989, and grew up in the role until 2001. Producers then wanted an older actor so Robert could take on more grown-up storylines.
Karl Davies took over in August 2001, and his feud with on-screen brother Andy helped Emmerdale beat EastEnders in a head-to-head ratings contest. Today Robert is played by Ryan Hawley, who first had the role from 2014 to 2019 and came back permanently in 2025.
Victoria Sugden
Jessica Haywood was the first Victoria, followed by Hannah Midgley, who took on the part as a young child in the late 1990s. Midgley left in July 2006 to concentrate on school.
Isabel Hodgins was 12 when she was cast as an older Victoria, and her first episode aired on 12 October 2006. She has played the role ever since.
Which Hollyoaks characters have been recast?
Liberty Savage
Abi Phillips created the role of Liberty. She found her way into the show by writing a song that was used in a Hollyoaks episode, and first appeared as Liberty in December 2010, aged 16. She was written out in 2013 and has since concentrated on music.
Liberty returned in June 2018 with Jessamy Stoddart, a musical theatre performer, in the role. Her storylines have included surrogacy and post-partum psychosis.
Which Home and Away characters have been recast?
Roo Stewart
Justine Clarke was one of the 17 original cast members of Home and Away, playing Alf Stewart's daughter Roo from 1988 to 1989. She later became a long-serving presenter of the ABC children's programme Play School.
Roo returned in 2010, played by two-time Gold Logie winner Georgie Parker. She still plays the role, and Roo and Alf are now the only two original characters left in the series.
Recast soap characters at a glance
| Character | Show | Earlier actor(s) | Current actor |
|---|---|---|---|
| Adam Barlow | Coronation Street | Iain De Caestecker | Sam Robertson |
| Nick Tilsley | Coronation Street | Adam Rickitt | Ben Price |
| Ryan Connor | Coronation Street | Ben Thompson, Sol Heras | Ryan Prescott |
| Summer Spellman | Coronation Street | Matilda Freeman | Harriet Bibby |
| Todd Grimshaw | Coronation Street | Bruno Langley | Gareth Pierce |
| Tracy Barlow | Coronation Street | Christabel Finch, Holly Chamarette, Dawn Acton | Kate Ford |
| Ash Panesar | EastEnders | Gurlaine Kaur Garcha | Sakira Vel |
| Chelsea Fox | EastEnders | Tiana Benjamin | Zaraah Abrahams |
| Elaine Peacock | EastEnders | Maria Friedman | Harriet Thorpe |
| Johnny Carter | EastEnders | Sam Strike, Ted Reilly | Charlie Suff |
| Lauren Branning | EastEnders | Madeline Duggan | Jacqueline Jossa |
| Mark Fowler | EastEnders | Ned Porteous | Stephen Aaron-Sipple |
| Penny Branning | EastEnders | Mia McKenna-Bruce | Kitty Castledine |
| Peter Beale | EastEnders | James Martin, Thomas Law, Ben Hardy, Dayle Hudson | Thomas Law (since 2023) |
| Vicki Fowler | EastEnders | Scarlett Alice Johnson | Alice Haig |
| Matty Barton | Emmerdale | Grace Cassidy (as Hannah Barton) | Ash Palmisciano |
| Robert Sugden | Emmerdale | Christopher Smith, Karl Davies | Ryan Hawley |
| Victoria Sugden | Emmerdale | Jessica Haywood, Hannah Midgley | Isabel Hodgins |
| Liberty Savage | Hollyoaks | Abi Phillips | Jessamy Stoddart |
| Roo Stewart | Home and Away | Justine Clarke | Georgie Parker |